For all those who are curious about similarities with Memento (debut movie of Christopher Nolan), let me tell you straight - Ghajini is not a copy of that awesome flick. And unfortunately, Ghajini is nowhere as good as Memento either....
The common thing between the two movies is the 'short term memory loss' syndrome - a condition where the person is unable to form new memories because of damage to the brain. In both movies, it happens because the villain clobbers the hero on his head with an iron rod - while killing his wife/fiance. And the hero swears vengeance ...
Aamir Khan plays Sanjay Singhania, a rich tycoon, who is smitten by the charms of a do-gooder, upcoming model Kalpana (Asin). He befriends her without revealing his identity and theirs is a sweet little romance (no kissing scenes and no cleavage show :) ) Then the unfortunate incident occurs and Aamir transforms into an animal - powerful and full of rage. His only motive in life is to hunt down Ghajini .... and he tries to find a trail to him with the help of tattoos, polaroid photos and notes.
Aamir's acting is superb as usual - one wonders how much time and effort he must have put in to make that beefcake body. His expressions, especially in the final sequences are frighteningly animal-like - and the action pulse pounding. He just literally smashes all the tamil-baddies with brute power. Its been sometime since we have seen such raw violence in mainstream hindi movies.
However unlike the previous few Aamir movies, this one disappoints big time. His acting notwithstanding, the plot is so full of holes, that even the simple linear storyline doesnt make sense. Lets start with his exact mental condition. Its not clear exactly what all can he remember - the professor at the start of the movie indicates that he doesnt remember anything personal apart from his love life. Yet later when Aamir loses his notes and photos, he doesnt remember anything about Kalpana as well !
Then more controversial is his short term memory - he is supposed to be able to remember things only for 15 min - yet this 15 min apparently can be stretched as long or squeezed short, as per the director's wishes. Neither is there any hint about how Aamir was able to trace Ghajini - there are maps and photos galore but no actual investigation shown.
But the most obvious plot hole is the final sequence. Doesnt it sound more than a little stupid, that not ONE among the 20-odd bodyguards of Ghajini would have a gun, when Aamir already warned them he was coming ?
There are other silly mistakes in the plot as well - but I think these are enough to give you an idea about whats wrong in the movie. And if the plot holes are not enough, there are the songs. Atrociously placed, each song is a drag on the storyline and has absolutely no requirement in the movie. Its almost as if Asin signed a contract that said she will have 3 songs picturized and Jiah Khan's contract said one song - so there ....
Among performances, Asin does a competent job, doing a few scenes well enough - but her role was quite dumbly written. Jiah Khan's role had nothing difficult and she is again competent. The villain Ghajini (I dont know his name but he used to appear in hindi movies before) does well too - especially the disdain with which he labels Aamir as 'short term memory loss'.
The movie is too long and the romantic track takes up too much time - especially at the end, with another needless song and closeups. The revenge track, which is supposed to be the main theme, unfortunately doesnt impress. The action can get you on the edge of your seat a few times, but with so many convenient shortcuts in the script, you stop believing the story. I personally found the final vengeance scene quite underwhelming too. Do yourself a favor and miss this movie - multiplex tickets are way too costly nowadays :)
1 comments:
I watched the movie today and I liked it. I think this movie deserves 3.5 stars. Frankly this film gave me the same satisfaction and entertainment that I had got years back when I had watched Mohra and Baazigar.
I agree, times have changed and films today have more intellectual content. But let me put it this way - any film well made will be appreciated and loved by people whether it is a remake, a masala movie or realistic movie.
"Ghajini is nowhere as good as Memento either" - Its not fair to say this because Ghajini was made keeping the indian people in mind. A non-linear approach to Ghajini would not have worked in India, this was an important theme of memento which made it an "awesome flick". Imagine a 3 hour long movie not in chronological order.
You are right when you say that the plot was full of holes, very true, but u must also take into account that this a typical masala movie with a love-story-revenge formula and not all such plots/subplots can be logically explained.
I dont think any mental condition can be explained by any doctor to a level where he can say what exactly he remembers and what he does not and to what exact duration he remembers. So when the doctor said that he only remembers his love life, he might have made an rough assumption that he may still remember people very close to him. But if he does not remember Kalpana then it does not become completely illogical - because it is a mental condition. A memory of 15 minutes can also extend to 35-40 minutes or even more because its not an established science that short term memory means 15 minutes memory.
Yes the absence of guns was noticeable but then the use of raw action with rods and punches and other super hero acts gave me more thrill.
The director could have been more innovative though when all tatoos and notes of aamir were destroyed.
I also got some reactions from the multiplex public. A small section of the people actually clapped at the end of the movie and i heard people discussing how well aamir acted and wondering how the tamil version of the movie was.
What i felt that at the end of the day even the multiplex going public ( and not only small town theatres ) got its value for money.
One of the reviewers actually wrote "Its Aamir's way of saying that if akshay and shahrukh can do it then he can do it too".
Post a Comment